New Evaluation Debunks the Assumption That Air Passenger Development Drives Financial Development

Assist CleanTechnica’s work via a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

Trade claims, usually echoed by governments to justify airport enlargement, that extra flights profit the financial system, undermined by new analysis.

The primary ever Europe-wide evaluation investigating the hyperlink between the expansion in air transport and financial development has discovered business claims that financial development is pushed by elevated air connectivity, akin to airport enlargement, are deeply flawed.

The examine from the New Economics Basis, and commissioned by T&E, analysed 274 European areas and reveals that the supposed hyperlink between air site visitors development and financial development is weaker than generally claimed. In 53% (143) of the areas analysed, a lot of Northern and Western Europe, the upper earnings of residents drives elevated air site visitors, not the opposite approach round. The evaluation finds that air site visitors development is most frequently a consequence of prosperity, not the reason for it.

The analysis examines the proof that air transport development is driving financial development throughout totally different areas utilizing a statistical clustering method. In areas of cluster 3 and 4 within the map above, the chance that air transport development was driving financial development was low and even unfavourable. In areas of clusters 1 and a couple of the chance was average.

“Permitting uncontrolled aviation development isn’t simply horrible local weather coverage, it’s dangerous financial coverage,” Denise Auclair, Head of T&E’s Journey Sensible Marketing campaign, says. “In giant elements of Europe, the aviation business claims that airport enlargement and ever extra flights carry financial development are merely not supported by the proof. It’s a pure business delusion that air site visitors development routinely brings sustainable job development and boosts the financial system. Governments shouldn’t be swayed by these claims, which additionally ignore the unfavourable penalties of air transport development. ”

Saturation in extremely related areas

The examine finds saturation in particular areas of Northern and Western Europe further air site visitors delivers diminishing and even unfavourable financial returns – that is designated as “saturation” by the analysis. That is the case for areas in Belgium, the Netherlands, the UK, and Germanythe place air journey is more and more dominated by folks holidaying overseas. Enterprise journey has stagnated or declined over the previous decade in most of North and Western Europe. Round three fourths of European nations have seen enterprise passenger numbers decline as in comparison with pre-pandemic ranges (2019-2024).

Regardless of the decline in enterprise journeys, the business claims that these areas, lots of that are already saturated, will profit from further company journey. Air site visitors development via airport expansions is underway in Frankfurt and nonetheless deliberate in London Heathrow and Brusselswith financial development used as an excuse for enlargement. These expansions are unjustified given the findings of this new examine and must be halted, T&E says.

“We’d like a wholesale rethink of Europe’s air transport technique. Airport expansions and capability selections should be guided by up-to-date proof, prioritising high quality, environmental impression, and equity over sheer numbers. Policymakers can now not depend on outdated assumptions to guage aviation’s financial worth,” says Dr Alex Chapman, senior Economist on the New Financial Basis.

In conventional tourism locations, lots of which present stagnating enterprise air journey, the hyperlink between air transport and financial development is extra advanced. That is the case for nations like Spain, Italy, and Portugal. The report highlights that the drop in financial worth from air tourism is formed by key components: guests are staying for shorter durations in lots of locations, the rise of casual lodging has weakened conventional tourism infrastructure, whereas good land transport and home tourism present lower-impact, precious alternate options to flying.

The typical size of keep in Southern European tourism locations has dropped from 4.3 nights across the yr 2000 to only 3.4 nights in 2023. This development in direction of shorter holidays is rising the transport prices share of vacationer journey expenditure in Europe, and is lowering the worth of every further journey.

The report additionally highlights the decrease environmental impression of highway and rail when substituted for air transport in these areas. Effectively related roads and rail can ship comparable financial advantages with fewer greenhouse gases.

Traditionally much less effectively related areas in Jap Europe have an air transport/financial development relationship much like that described by researchers in Western Europe within the Nineties and early 2000s. Their decrease degree of improvement and connectivity, mixed with rising enterprise journey demand, leaves room to connectivity-led financial development.

Information launch from T&E.