Contact ‘n Go RFID MLFF vs PLUS JustGo ANPR – Malaysian highways to have competing toll methods?

Now that Contact ‘n Go has entered the multi-lane quick circulation (MLFF) area – because it was sure to do given its near-monopoly of toll funds – freeway concessionaires now have a companion to assist implement a barrier-less, high-speed toll assortment system. However it gained’t be all easy crusing, as this time across the mentioned concessionaires have the flexibility to buy round for an answer that works for them.

One freeway operator that has determined to go its personal manner is PLUS Malaysia, which is about to trial its computerized quantity plate recognition (ANPR) system on the North-South Freeway this month, utilizing its JustGo app for funds. Now, this clearly begs the query – does this imply there will likely be a number of competing MLFF toll assortment methods? And if that’s the case, does that imply us Malaysians should obtain a separate app for every of our nation’s quite a few highways?

Earlier than we get forward of ourselves, let’s take a look at how every system operates. The MLFF answer that Contact ‘n Go is presently Piloting on the Kemuning-Shah Alam Freeway (LKSA) retains the RFID tags the corporate presently makes use of, however provides a brand new reader and a high-powered antenna from Star Programs Worldwide (SSI). This permits the system to learn tags extra precisely and reliably – addressing the primary disadvantage of the present RFID setup.

That is supported by an ANPR digital camera and a 3D lidar sensor as a fallback, serving to to detect the automobiles that handle to slide via the cracks. In keeping with SSI, the pilot system – which makes use of knowledge from a close-by toll plaza for validation – achieved 100% automobile detection and has learn over 99.98% of current TnG RFID tags.

The most important benefit of TnG’s system is that it integrates a cost technique that already exists – the RFID and eWallet mixture that’s used for the overwhelming majority of highways right here. Clients is not going to must get new tags or set up a brand new utility, sidestepping the effort of adopting a brand new system. Nonetheless, it stays to be seen if TnG’s answer works in addition to it (or not less than its companion) claims, given the problems which have dogged the present RFID system for toll funds.

In the meantime, PLUS’ system solely makes use of ANPR know-how and reportedly works with the cameras already put in at its toll cubicles for surveillance, allotting with the necessity for RFID tags, readers and antennas. All that’s required is a legible quantity plate which, let’s be actual, is simpler mentioned than completed in Malaysia.

The JustGo app is required to register for the system, however not like the Contact ‘n Go eWallet app, this isn’t an digital pockets in and of itself – customers might want to hyperlink it with their cost technique of their selection, together with credit score/debit playing cards and, crucially, the TnG eWallet itself. Each apps function digital know your buyer (eKYC) know-how for account verification, stopping unauthorised transactions.

The strategy chosen by PLUS requires a bit extra effort on the person’s half however needs to be less expensive for the corporate to implement, because it gained’t must pay for costly RFID gear. The flexibility to make use of a TnG eWallet as one of many cost strategies additionally eliminates having to maintain monitor of a number of accounts.

We must always level out that the ANPR system is presently being trialled with obstacles nonetheless in place, so it’s unclear if the know-how is ready to be scaled as much as a full-blown MLFF setup with a number of lanes of fast-moving visitors.

Relying solely on quantity plates for recognition additionally opens up the system to the potential of unscrupulous motorists gaming it – witness the latest case of 1 highway person manipulating their plate quantity to evade quite a few fines from AWAS velocity cameras, just by eradicating a single letter. As for the draw back to customers, nicely, it’s yet one more app to obtain…

Which brings us to our most important concern – if every of the 33 freeway concessionaires select to implement their very own competing MLFF system, does that imply we’ll all must obtain 33 separate apps? We actually hope not, and we count on the federal government to intervene earlier than the scenario will get out of hand.

To be trustworthy, we’re not shocked that TnG and PLUS have determined to go their separate methods, provided that the 2 corporations have a historical past of sparring with regards to toll cost strategies. In 2018, not lengthy after TnG revealed its RFID system, PLUS introduced its plan to introduce a competing product – just for TnG dad or mum CIMB to search an injunction blocking the transferciting a breach of contract. Initially, PLUS mentioned its RFID system didn’t run afoul of any settlementbut it surely deserted the mission quickly after anyway.

Even now, having ultimately adopted TnG’s RFID setup, PLUS is constant to drag its toes with the implementation of the PayDirect systemwhich allows toll fares to be deducted straight from a person’s eWallet. Even the works ministry has needed to step in, instructing PLUS to allow PayDirect on the North-South Freeway by this month. Which MLFF system are you supporting? Tell us within the feedback.

Seeking to promote your automobile? Promote it with Automobile.